A judge has discretion at sentencing, but that discretion has limits. The punishment must have a legal basis. A recent Virginia Court of Appeals decision shows why checking the jail term and fine is not always enough.
The court must also have authority for any additional punishment it imposes.
The additional punishment in Hopkins
In Hopkins v. Commonwealth, decided October 13, 2026, a defendant convicted of misdemeanor assault and battery received 12 months in jail, a $500 fine, and an indefinite ban from a treatment provider’s premises.
The Court of Appeals held that the trial court lacked authority under the misdemeanor punishment statute to add that premises ban. It vacated the entire sentence and returned the case for resentencing. The assault conviction remained intact.
The fact that the fine was below the statutory maximum did not authorize a different kind of punishment. Nor did the defendant’s failure to object at sentencing prevent review: the Court treated the sentencing order as void from its inception.
The distinction involving probation matters
This decision does not mean judges can never impose a stay-away condition. Hopkins had no suspended portion of his sentence. The Court expressly distinguished its holding from conditions imposed through the court’s authority over suspended sentences and probation.
Virginia Code § 19.2-303 gives courts authority to suspend sentences and impose probation conditions. Whether a particular restriction is lawful requires examining the statutory basis and the actual order. You cannot resolve that question by looking at the restriction in isolation.
Why the sentencing order deserves careful review
Virginia Code § 18.2-11 sets the general punishment range for misdemeanor classes. Other statutes can impose additional requirements in particular cases. Reviewing a sentence means identifying all of the provisions that apply.
As a former prosecutor and defense attorney, I want the client to understand both what the judge imposed and what the written order requires. How much time is active? How much is suspended? What conditions apply, for how long, and under what authority?
Those details affect the decisions a person makes after leaving court. A misunderstanding about a condition can lead to another court appearance and potentially a revocation proceeding.
A resentencing is not a dismissal
It is important to distinguish relief from a sentence from relief from the underlying conviction. A new sentencing hearing does not necessarily end the case or guarantee a lower lawful sentence.
Before challenging an order, an attorney needs to explain the relief that may be available and the practical consequences of returning for sentencing. The goal is informed advice grounded in the actual record.
Do not assume an order can be ignored
If something in your order appears improper, get legal advice promptly. Do not stop complying based on a headline or your own reading of this case. Deadlines and procedural requirements can affect how a challenge must be brought, and many errors do not receive the same treatment as the order in Hopkins.
Keep your final order, plea paperwork, and probation instructions together. Ask your attorney to explain anything that is unclear before it becomes a compliance problem.
Dischley Law represents people facing criminal charges in Northern Virginia. Contact our office to discuss a pending case and the sentencing issues it may present.